Why On Earth Did Marissa Mayer Say Yes to Yahoo?

Bookmark and Share

Yahoo has had its “grown up” Valley CEO.

It has had its studio mogul CEO.

It has had its returning visionary founder CEO.

It has had its hard-charging, execution-centric CEO.

It has had its misrepresenting, train-wreck, patent troll CEO.

And now, with the stunning appointment of Marissa Mayer, Yahoo tries to go yet another route: A CEO with bona-fide Web tech chops. Give the new board credit for one thing: At least it’s not repeating mistakes of the past.

This announcement has sent the Valley into utter confusion and disbelief. It was a move that even Yahoo soothsayers AllThingsD couldn’t anticipate, and certainly one that has made interim CEO and fellow candidate Ross Levinsohn very unhappy.

The stunning part isn’t that Yahoo wanted Mayer. She has been one of the most hotly recruited Valley executives for years. It’s that Mayer actually said yes.

Even Jason Kilar of Hulu reportedly said no, and no offense to Kilar, but he’s no Marissa Mayer. She’s Sheryl Sandberg-like in her ability to be a polished spokeswoman and an effective take-no-bullshit executive, but she also has technical chops that aren’t always part of that package. And having seen her in action as a final judge at TechCrunch Disrupt for years, I can attest that she has an uncanny ability to know where technology is going, what is truly disruptive, and what will and will not resonate with consumers. (And she’s got some sweet dance moves, as we saw from the Ed Lee video last year… Sorry, Marissa. That gif is not going away.) She’s not just a dream candidate for Yahoo; she’s a dream candidate for nearly anyone.

Does her decision merely telegraph Mayer’s ambition, that after years helping guide several divisions at one of the most powerful technology companies in Valley history, she is not only ready to be a CEO but do a good job in a corner office that has made anyone who came close to it look incompetent? Or does Mayer know something we do not?

I haven’t talked to her, and won’t pretend to hazard a guess.

It’s easy to think of Mayer as a “new Tim Armstrong” — a successful, well-heralded Google exec. who may have looked good as part of Google, but could well struggle taking on an aging, dysfunctional Web giant. That playbook hasn’t worked well for Armstrong, and arguably Mayer is taking on an even more dysfunctional Web giant with Yahoo.

But Armstrong was a sales guy; Mayer is a technologist. The move seems to telegraph that Yahoo will be going back to its roots, focusing her design and product eye on strengths like mail, finance and sports, but I doubt that means she’s going the sheer news and media direction that Armstrong took AOL even with Yahoo’s strengths in these areas. And my guess is Mayer will put her connections and talents picking good upcoming startups to work with some acquisitions. I’m honestly not sure if that’s a good thing, but if I’m right, at least it’s a strategy.

Having closely watched Yahoo through most of these CEOs, it’s hard to be optimistic. I think an organization this beleaguered, this bloated, this siloed needs more than a great CEO. But I can say for the first time in the last three CEO hires, Yahoo may have its first real shot at regaining relevance in a long time.

This article brought to you by our content partnership with Pando Daily.

Sarah Lacy is the founder and editor-in-chief of PandoDaily. She is an award winning journalist and author of two critically acclaimed books, “Once You’re Lucky, Twice You’re Good: The Rebirth of Silicon Valley and the Rise of Web 2.0″ (Gotham Books, May 2008) and “Brilliant, Crazy, Cocky: How the Top 1% of Entrepreneurs Profit from Global Chaos” (Wiley, February 2011). She has been covering technology news for over 15 years, most recently as a senior editor for TechCrunch.

 

You might also like:

Comments

Latest Posts

Kickstarter: Crowd Funding Your Creativity

July 19th, 2012

Kickstarter does what its name implies: It gives creative projects a kick-start through online crowd funding. Entrepreneurs can raise money from independent investors (friends, family, or the general online community) while still retaining ownership over their product. Thus instead of profit percentage, investors receive rewards. Think free copies (of the documentary, book or game) or an opportunity to meet the creator.

Since the recent explosive success of Ouya, an independent TV gaming console, Kickstarter has been making headlines. Projects listed are diverse and often funky. For example, current ventures include 100% organic Beef Jerky and a Bike-in Theater.

Our Picks: Thursday’s Top Political Stories

July 19th, 2012

The day’s most provocative takes:

McKay Coppins says the biting tone of the latest counterattacks by the Mitt Romney gang are no accident. He quotes an adviser as saying, “I think the governor himself believes this latest round of attacks that have impugned his integrity and accused him of being a felon go so far beyond that pale that he’s really disappointed. He believes it’s time to vet the president.” And there’s this: “The Republican’s campaign is now prepared to go eye for an eye in an intense, no-holds-barred act of political reprisal, said two Romney advisers who spoke on condition of anonymity.” An ugly campaign is about to get uglier. (Buzzfeed)

An intriguing piece in the Huffington Post says  that Romney “has been confident that he will never be forced to do so, several current and former Bain executives tell The Huffington Post. Had he thought otherwise, say the sources based on their longtime understanding of Romney, he never would have gone forward with his run for president.” But wait–it bears the co-byline of Abby Huntsman. Should a daughter who helped her father, former Utah governor Jon Huntsman, campaign against Romney really be reporting on Mitt’s campaign? (HuffPost)

Fox News commentator Ed Rollins, the former campaign manager for Michele Bachmann, rips his former client as “extreme and dishonest” for trying to tie Hillary aide Huma Abedin (Anthony Weiner’s wife) to the Muslim Brotherhood. “Having worked for Congressman Bachman’s campaign for president, I am fully aware that she sometimes has difficulty with her facts, but this is downright vicious and reaches the late Senator Joe McCarthy  level.” The man does not mince words. (Fox News)

How Journalists Should Harness Crowdsourcing

July 19th, 2012

Journalists should think of themselves as curators rather than exclusive content creators.

In the summer 2012 issue of Nieman Reports from Harvard, Mark Little, founder of the social media news outlet Storyful, explains that journalists should harness the power of the increasingly active audience–rather than hope that readers will passively swallow whatever content is produced, as they did in the past. Storyful uses the hands of human editors and online tools such as Google Maps to validate online accounts in the new “golden hour” of newsgathering – the time when social media is pushing emerging stories to the headlines. Reporters cannot keep up with the 24/7 news cycle alone, so they should learn to curate the ever-growing mass of online content rather than insist of producing everything alone.

Is 2012 Election a Time for “Crisis”?

July 19th, 2012

Peggy Noonan might not be able to read your palms, but the Wall Street Journal columnist thinks she knows how you “talk” and “think” about the upcoming presidential election. She knows, for instance, that you know “that who we pick now really matters.” She also knows why you’re not that excited about the election this year.

Calling the election a “crisis election like 1932 or 1980,” Noonan theorizes that “behind the general lack of passion” is my and your double awareness “that what America needs right now is the leadership of a kind of political genius” and “that neither [Barack Obama nor Mitt Romney] is a political genius.”

Does Facebook Care if You’re Under 13?

July 19th, 2012

After reading Politico’s article about Facebook allowing children under 13 to join the site, it was hard to say which of beloved Facebook’s statements was the bigger piece of bunk.

Piece of Bunk #1: The pseudo naiveté of Facebook’s chief privacy officer Erin Egan in saying that “the age gate we use…does not always prevent children from entering.”

Take another look at the sign-up form (it’s not very hard to find; log out [!], and it’s right there). Beneath the “your” birthday input there’s a link, intentionally in small font, that asks, “Why do I need to provide my birthday?”